No they all suck.
Rebooting originals gives 10x better product. Anything else is a waste of time and garbage.
Granted, easy train is so enticing you won’t be able to resist until one cuts loose on the interstate and you’re stranded and learn by experience, like many of us have done. So, ignore me, but keep your originals for when the “new” ones fail.
“Heavy Duty” on Subaru axles is marketing click bait. It’s nonsense for so many reasons but chiefly old Subaru’s don’t support a market for quality axles. Cheap people will buy cheap and wise owners of reliable daily drivers will reboot Subaru axles. There’s nearly zero market for more expensive quality axles. If there was I’d buy 100 OEM and rebuild them myself and sell them. But it doesn’t exist. Companies know this better than me.
The last “heavy duty” axles new to the market I said there’s no possible way they’re any good. Someone on here swore they were worth trying and wanted them to be all that. they were garbage and he had issues with them. Maybe the same trash you’re looking at. HD something or the other.
ive seen brand new axles blow up in less than 100 miles multiple times, or click, clack, or vibrate, they’re terrible. I wouldn’t trust one or feel good about it if it did install and had no symptoms at first.
The good Subaru specialty shops buy Subaru OEM axles from the dealer or rebuild or buy used OEM ones.