My wife and I have a 2014 Forester. Hands down the worst car we have ever owned. That being said, we probably got a lemon.
That being said, Subaru denied our claim on oil consumption, had the dealership replace the block at cost... We had two blocks fail (both rod bearings) within 500 miles.
CV axles went out within 80k miles
Occupant detection mat went out in passenger seat
Driver heated seats went out(havw to replace the entire seat to fix)
AC compressor went out in under 100k
Radio went out at 40k
Neutral safety switch went out
And last, but not least, bulkhead Wiring Harness failed (I think the damage was a result from the engine removal).
Currently waiting for the CVT to go as we're at 142k, but so far it's been okay...
I would buy the 2010.