I'm done with brakes... didn't even check rotors before replacing them. Just bought new rotors and new pads and replaced everything in an hour. 14mm to remove calipers, 17mm to remove caliper brackets, nice size hammer to get the rotors loose and I'm done. Good thing you mentioned that I should check for deposits on rotors after a while. I might want to take the wheels off and send/hone rotors with some fine sand paper down the road. Question though... after replacing rotors I have noticed that old rotors would not fit into original boxes that my new rotors came into. Is it possible that I bought rotors for a Legacy? FLAPS mistake? Is the size difference noticable? I have no problems with brakes, they work great (well, for Subaru anyway)... brakes are not really a Subaru's strong side.