Well... as it turns out, she was being just a tad conservative as far as dents and dings go.
http://s19.photobucket.com/albums/b164/Ryoga77/Subaru/?albumview=grid
There are previous signs of standing water in the spare wheel well, though I was almost expecting that. It was all very dry today. Based on what I saw, it's probably the apparently common tail light leak. There is also some advanced rust behind the left rear wheel (pictured). That's the only place I noticed rust through, though those rear fenders probably aren't far behind.
The interior is straight (no rips, cracks, etc.) but it is quite dirty. Not to mention one of the owners apparently letting their kids put stickers all over the back windows.
And it's actually in desperate need of tires. There would be no waiting until winter.
The passenger mirror is non-functional, and the rear wiper doesn't park itself. All other electrical items appear to be in good working order. A/C and heat work well.
There is also something amiss in the right front of the car (like the tire wasn't a give away, right?) as it likes to pull to the right. It's especially noticeable at highway speeds in a left curve. What ever the issue is, it causes involuntary sawing at the wheel as it tries to go right. It's not severe, but still an issue. It also exhibited what I could only describe as mild torque steer at times. Though again, there's clearly something out of alignment or worn out up there. The right front also had some detectable slop when yanked on at a 10 and 3 position with the wheel on the ground. It wasn't anything drastic, but it was detectable. I didn't have a jack with me (that I would trust) to allow further investigation unfortunately.
The engine is mostly clean except for some greasy build up at the base of the intake on both heads. I attempted to get some pictures of that. The underside was pretty clean, as were the transmission and rear differential. Whether it's really that clean, or it's been cleaned off at some point is hard to say. The fluids were all good. The fan cycled properly and the temp gauge stayed right around the half way point. The exhaust was disappointingly quiet.
I tested for torque bind (something I wouldn't have known to look for before finding this board ), and there appear to be no issues there. Other than a barely perceptible bump when it up shifts to 2nd (and I do mean barely), the transmission was very smooth.
The brakes were also fine with no pulling or vibrations. And the ABS also appeared to be working quite well. Well, I didn't get any wheel lock ups on dry pavement at about 25 mph at any rate. Though I didn't test it on any gravel, etc. I didn't notice any noise or pulsating or have any indication that the ABS actually did anything (other than no lock up). Is the ABS that smooth and quiet (I've had no experience with Subaru ABS systems), or are the brakes on that car possibly just weak under load? I certainly didn't detect any other issues with the brakes during normal driving.
Overall, other than the issue in the front, the car does drive rather nicely.
I was very disappointed with how bad the body is torn up. The service history is still up in the air as she doesn't know where the paper work is at. I do not doubt that she has it, but it is misplaced at present. I told her I'd be hard pressed to give any more than $2000. And as I think about it, even that might be more than I'd like to give. The drive line may be great, but I've had too many beat up looking cars already. Who knows, in another week or so I may get that desperate, but I'm not there... yet.
Oh yeah, she's basing her price off of the KBB fair appraisal minus the cost of tires (the cheapest from Sam's Club). I mentioned to her that both NADA and Edmund's value the car much lower.
Opinions?
And sorry for the ridiculously long post everyone!