Off and on for a little over a year the starter has been making a screeching noise on cold starts, (so my wife says, I've never heard it until just recently).
Being a mechanic on boats and lawn and garden equipment for 40 years I could tell instantly that the bendix was not releasing from the flywheel.
Either a faulty ignition switch or a sticky bendix will do this.
My question is; Does Subaru have any issues with starters or ignition switches in 2005 on Outback wagons?