I'm new here and admittedly don't know very much about cars.
My husband and I purchased a used 2008 Subaru Outback about a year and a half ago (current mileage is about 120,000). When we got approved for the loan through a bank, they offered us a lower interest rate if we purchased an extended warranty. We sprung for a three year, top of the line warranty, set to cover absolutely everything with a $200 deductible.
Last week, we noticed the AC getting warm. Then, my husband was driving the car and it overheated. We put more oil into the car because it seemed a little low, and attributed the issue to a bad water pump. We waited until the car cooled back down and took it directly to the dealership.
Unfortunately, we need a new head gasket (which I'm reading is a somewhat normal thing for this model) and we have a leaky radiator. The warranty company is not wanting to pay, and claiming that we put something into the radiator to keep it from leaking because there is a "gooey" substance in there. Cost of all repairs without warranty? $1900.
I need to know what else could be causing a gooey substance, and what points I can bring up with the warranty company. I feel like I'm being scammed, and that it could be a multitude of things, and why would I put anything into the radiator when I'm paying good money to have my repairs covered?
The dealership advised me to call the warranty company and complain, which I am ready to do. I just want information to back me up, because I didn't do anything!
Thanks in advance for any replies.